Webster’s Dictionary defines weaning as “accustoming a young mammal to take food otherwise than by nursing.” Although this event may be very cut and dried in the animal world, for humans the process of weaning is much more complicated, but only because we make it that way.
Weaning your baby is part of the natural breastfeeding experience. It doesn’t have to be a time of unhappiness for you or your baby. If done “gradually, and with love” (the La Leche League motto), weaning can be a positive experience for both you and your little one.
Ideally, your baby will nurse until he outgrows the need. This is called natural, or baby-led weaning. Every baby has different “needs” in different areas. For example, some babies need to be held almost constantly, while others squirm and wiggle if you try to hold them too long, and are perfectly content to sit in their playpen for an hour or so while they entertain themselves. Some babies need lots of sleep – they take regular three hour naps, and are sleeping through the night by the time they’re a few weeks old, while others cat nap infrequently and are still waking up at night when they’re two years old. Just as you would not set an arbitrary limit on other areas of your baby’s development, such as deciding exactly when he will sit up, roll over, move into a bed instead of a crib, etc. (instead, you watch for signs that he is ready to move on to the next developmental stage), it just makes sense not to set an arbitrary time limit on how long you will nurse your baby.
Weaning should be a process, rather than an event. You actually begin weaning your baby the very first time you offer him any food other than your milk. (See Starting Solids). Depending on how you go about it, weaning can be abrupt or gradual, and may take days, weeks, or months. Abrupt weaning should always be avoided, if at all possible, for the sake of both you and your baby. If you suddenly stop nursing, your breasts will respond by becoming engorged, and you may develop a breast infection or breast abscess. Your hormone levels drop abruptly, and depression can result. Mothers with a history of depression should especially consider this when making decisions about weaning. Abruptly withdrawing the breast can cause emotional trauma in the baby. Since nursing is not only a source of food for a baby, but a source of security and emotional comfort as well, taking it away abruptly can be very disturbing. There is absolutely no way to explain to a baby why he suddenly can’t nurse anymore. Weaning gradually lets you slowly substitute other kinds of attention to help compensate for the loss of the closeness of nursing.
If you are told to wean your baby abruptly for medical reasons, you need to make sure that there are no other options. It is well worth getting a second opinion from someone who is knowledgeable about breastfeeding. Most of the time, you’ll find that there are alternatives. For example, if you are prescribed a medication that is incompatible with breastfeeding, ask your doctor to see if another, safer drug can be substituted.
First of all, make sure that the drug really is unsafe to take while nursing – often doctors who aren’t really sure will err on the side of caution and tell you to wean, rather than doing a little research (beyond the limited lactation information given in the PDR -Physician’s Desk Reference) to get more detailed information about the drug’s effect on the nursing infant. Pediatricians and obstetricians are more likely to have access to this detailed information than doctors in other fields, such as dentists or anesthesiologists, yet these doctors often make recommendations about weaning, without the benefit of a broad knowledge base of lactation.
There are resources available that can tell your doctor exactly how long a drug stays in your system, how much is transferred into your milk, and what side effects to look for. Unfortunately, many doctors don’t know that these resources exist, and may or may not be willing to do a little research to access them. In many cases, it’s just easier for them to tell the mother to wean. Tell your health care provider to contact Dr. Thomas Hale’s Infant Risk Center (www.infantrisk.org) to find information about the safety of specific medications during breastfeeding.
Even if your doctor feels that you have to take a drug that isn’t safe while nursing, you have the option of just weaning temporarily and picking up breastfeeding where you left off. This involves expressing your milk during the interim, so that you will ready to resume nursing, and also to avoid engorgement. A hospital grade electric pump is better for this purpose than a manual or small electric pump. These can be rented for short-term use. If you absolutely have to stop nursing suddenly and permanently (this rarely happens – the most common reason would be the mother who was diagnosed with cancer, and has to begin chemotherapy immediately), the article on Lactation Suppression has tips on how to minimize the physical discomfort of abrupt weaning.
There are many, many benefits to extended breastfeeding, and very few benefits to weaning early. That is not to say that even one feeding at the breast doesn’t have value, because it does. Whether you nurse for days, weeks, or years, breastfeeding provides both you and your baby with many important benefits – but breastfeeding for a year or longer offers the most advantages. Extended breastfeeding is definitely not the norm in this country – worldwide, most babies are weaned between two and four years – but in the US, fewer than 20% of babies are still nursing when they are six months old. While you may find it hard to imagine a mother in India nursing a three year old, that same mother would probably be baffled at the idea of taking a baby off the breast when he was just a few weeks old.
Through millions of years of human history, extended breastfeeding has been the norm. It’s only been in the past century that we’ve seen a shift toward earlier and earlier weaning, and the reasons are not based on scientific fact, but rather on a number of cultural influences. One problem is that in our society, breasts have been turned into sexual objects rather than feeding devices for infants, which was, after all, their original function. Barbara Hey (the mother of a nursing toddler) wrote: “Breasts will never be considered ‘run-of-the-mill’ body parts. Pull out a bottle and a crowd gathers; lift up your shirt and the room clears”. Many people associate breasts with sexuality, and breastfeeding with something dirty, especially if your baby is a boy. The same people who totally freak out at the idea of a toddler nursing don’t think twice about an older baby who sucks his thumb, or hauls around a security blanket.
If you decide to go with natural, or baby-led, weaning, be prepared for lots and lots of unsolicited advice. You will be told that you’re doing it for you, not the baby (this is ridiculous, because it is a proven fact that you absolutely cannot make a baby nurse if he doesn’t want to – try it sometime if you don’t believe me). You will be told that your child will become a sexual deviant (yep, I bet if you took a survey you’d find that prisons are just chock full of men who were breastfed till they were ready to wean…touch of sarcasm here).
You will be told that your child will become hopelessly dependent on you, and you’ll be following him to Kindergarten to nurse at rest time. Interestingly enough, experience and research have shown that babies who are nursed until they are ready to wean are actually less dependent because their security needs have been met as infants – they tend to separate more easily from their mothers and move into new relationships with more stability. It really boils down to following your instincts as a mother – nobody knows this little individual better than you, and you will know when he is ready to wean and move on to a new stage in your relationship.
- There are many benefits of extended breastfeeding. The AAP (American Academy of Pediatrics) recommends nursing for at least the first year of your baby’s life, and WHO (World Health Organization) recommends breastfeeding for at least two years.
- For as long as you breastfeed, your baby continues to get the immunological advantages of human milk, during a time when he is increasingly exposed to infection. Breastfed toddlers are healthier overall.
- When your toddler is upset, hurt, frightened, or sick, you have a built in way to comfort him. Often a sick child will accept breast milk when he refuses other foods.
- Many of the medical benefits of breastfeeding (lower cancer risk in mother and baby, for example) are dose related – in other words, the longer you breastfeed, the greater the protective effects (see article Why Breastfeed for more details).
- Human milk offers protection for the child who is allergic.
- Mothering a toddler is challenging enough – nursing makes the job of caring for and comforting him easier. There is no better way to ease a temper tantrum, or put a cranky child to sleep than by nursing.
- Nursing provides closeness, security, and stability during a period of rapid growth and development.
- Letting your baby set the pace for weaning spares you the unpleasant task of weaning him before he is ready. It is important to remember that all children wean eventually. If you are sitting at the computer with a two week old infant in your arms, who is having marathon nursing sessions around the clock, it is probably hard to imagine nursing a toddler. Nursing an older baby is totally different from nursing a newborn. Forget those forty-five minute nursing sessions. Toddlers climb in your lap when they fall and bump their knee, nurse for a couple of minutes, and they’re done. They will have longer sessions (usually bedtime or nap-time), but they’re way too busy exploring their world to spend too much time nursing. They also don’t nurse as often – maybe every four to five hours, rather than every two to three. Because of this difference in nursing patterns, you are not nearly as tied down with an older nursing baby as you are with a newborn.
There’s another phenomenon that comes into play here. When you look at your one or two or three year old, he will still be your baby. It doesn’t matter if he has skinned knees and peanut butter smeared on his mouth, he is still a tiny little person with lots of growing up to do. It’s a tough world out there, and before you know it he’ll be too big to hold your hand, much less nurse. Why rush him?
Ask any mother with older children and she’ll tell you the same thing – babies grow up way too fast, and when you look back on it, the time he spent nursing (even if it was several years) is a very small piece of the pie. He’ll live at home for 18 years, and even if he nurses for three or four of those years… – well, you do the math. I like this quote, but don’t know who said it. “We have 18 years to teach our children independence. Why try to do it all in the first years?”
It should be obvious that I have a bias toward baby-led weaning. It just makes sense to me on so many levels. If someone tells you that babies shouldn’t be nursed past six months, or one year, try asking them “Why”? They will be hard put to come up with a reason that makes sense, much less one that they can back up with any empirical evidence.
This is not to say that I think long term nursing is right for everyone. When to wean is a very individual decision, and sometimes early weaning is the right thing for you and your baby. If a baby is not happy and thriving, and you’re so stressed that you can’t enjoy the time you spend with him, then it may be time to wean. Most babies do just fine on formula, and breastfeeding at all costs is not the most important consideration.
You also need to be aware than nursing for days or weeks (or even one feeding at the breast) still offers important benefits to your baby.
Nursing should never be an endurance contest. If you do decide that early weaning is right for you and your baby, here are some guidelines to follow:
- Try to do it as gradually as possible. Eliminate one feeding each day for several days to allow your milk supply to decrease slowly. After a couple of weeks, he should be down to nursing just a couple of times a day. Usually the last feedings to go are the first one in the morning, and the last one at night. If you’re not in a huge rush, you may want to continue these couple of feedings for another week or two.
- Talk to your baby’s doctor to find out what formula he recommends. Since babies are not ready for cow’s milk until they are a year old, it is important to find the appropriate formula. Since young babies have a strong need to suck, offer a substitute (bottle or pacifier). Some babies will find their thumbs during this period, and there’s not much you can do about that one way or the other. There are advantages to having a thumb-sucker – those babies tend to be self-soothers, and often are better sleepers and travelers than babies who depend on pacifiers.
- Offer lots of physical closeness during this time. There is a tendency to avoid cuddling, because the baby associates the nursing position with breastfeeding, but it is important to snuggle your baby and get lots of skin-to-skin contact, even if you avoid the cradle hold. If the decision is left up to them, most babies will wean themselves gradually, beginning by cutting back on nursing around the time they start solids.
Physically, most toddlers are “ready” to wean. They are eating a variety of solid foods, and breast milk is no longer their sole source of nutrition. Nursing a child who is no longer an infant is done more out of concern for his psychological and emotional needs than for his nutritional ones, although he does receive protective health benefits as long as he nurses.
There are some older babies who make the transition from infancy to toddler-hood without the slightest indication of readiness to wean. Weaning an older child who isn’t ready can be a real challenge. You should not feel guilty if you decide to wean your toddler, because only you know when the time is right for you and your family. For example, you may be pregnant again, and while that in and of itself is not a reason to wean, your nipples may be so sore that you are gritting your teeth and not enjoying nursing your toddler AT ALL. He may begin to pick up on your feelings of resentment, and it may be time to wean.
When deciding to wean a toddler, it is important to remember that he received the benefits of breastfeeding for many months (far surpassing the average) and so you have absolutely nothing to feel guilty about if you decide it is time to end your nursing relationship and move on to the next stage.
Weaning an older baby doesn’t have to be traumatic, although it may not be easy.
Here are some tips:
- If possible, allow several weeks of concentrated time and attention to the process of weaning. Any baby who has nursed for a year or more is obviously really into it, and isn’t likely to give it up easily.
- Don’t offer, but don’t refuse. Nurse him only when he is really adamant about it, but don’t offer to nurse at other times.
- Make sure that you offer regular meals, snacks, and drinks to minimize hunger and thirst.
- Remember also that babies nurse for reasons besides hunger, including comfort, boredom, and to fall asleep. Try to change your daily routine to minimize situations where he wants to nurse. Does he want to nurse when he is bored? Try distracting him with a snack or a walk outside. Do you usually lie down with him at nap time? Try reading him a book or rocking him instead.
- If dad is around, encourage him to take an active role in weaning. Have dad try to put him back to sleep if he wakes during the night. If he nurses first thing in the morning, try letting dad get him up instead of you and feed him breakfast.
- Watch his preferences and respect them. If he is having a really hard time giving up the first thing in the morning nursing, or the bedtime nursing, you may want to continue that one for a while rather than force the issue.
- With older toddlers (two years plus) you can begin to set limits on nursing. For example, you can say “We’ll nurse when we get home, but not at the mall”.
- Substitute nursing on demand for nursing at your convenience. This theory also works for security objects (pacifiers or blankets) – for example, “You can’t take your blankie to pre-school, but it will be on your bed waiting for you when you get home”.
- Shorten the duration of any given feeding. Say “That’s enough, now.” and gently remove the breast from his mouth. I’ve used a kitchen timer before when I was pregnant and nursing a toddler. My nipples were so sore that I could only nurse for a few minutes at a time, but that bedtime nursing was still important to her, so she learned that after five – or four – or three – minutes, the timer would go off and it would be time for her to stop. As long as she knew she could still nurse some of the time, she was okay with it.
In summary: weaning is a process that begins as soon as you introduce solid foods into your baby’s diet. This comes in handy when someone asks you if you have started weaning him yet – you can truthfully answer “yes”. Babies wean at different ages, just as they get teeth at different ages. When you wean your baby is a decision for you to make, ideally based on signs of developmental readiness.
Breastfeeding provides benefits for both you and your baby no matter how long you nurse. Gradual weaning is always better than abrupt weaning, although there are times when this just isn’t possible. If you and your child both enjoy nursing, and your only reason for weaning is that you are under pressure from other people who think you should, then you need to look further for outside support of your decision to continue nursing. If you no longer enjoy nursing, or if there are legitimate pressing reasons for you to wean, you should do it and feel good about the time you did nurse, without feeling guilty about what might have been.
On a personal note: I have nursed six children. The first three weaned themselves before they were a year old. I was a La Leche League leader at the time, and all my friends were nursing their toddlers. I couldn’t believe my babies were doing that to me – I was willing to nurse them till they went to college, but there was absolutely no way to convince them to keep nursing once they decided they were done. Even withholding food didn’t work.
My experience with my next three babies reminded me of the old adage “Be careful what you wish for”, because they all wanted to nurse between two and five years, and I thought they were never going to be ready to wean.
It was interesting to me that my early weaners were all thumb-suckers and blanket holders, while my late weaners were never self-soothers, but used the breast for comfort as well as nutrition. All were breastfed on demand from day one, so I can only assume that individual differences accounted for the different weaning experiences. I am happy to report that all six have turned out relatively normal and well adjusted, so their radically different weaning schedules apparently didn’t have a long term effect on their development. I’m so glad – with six children, I have plenty of other things to feel guilty about.
Anne Smith, IBCLC
(Edited September 2016)
*Please ‘Pay it Forward’!*
If you found this article helpful, please consider making a small donation to my favorite cause – “Project Pets: Spay, Neuter, Love”, an all volunteer, non-profit organization that provides free spay and neuter services for homeless rescue dogs and cats…because every baby deserves a home, whether they have two legs or four! To find out more about how you can help, visit Project Pets on Facebook.
There are many, many benefits to extended breastfeeding, and very few benefits to weaning early. That is not to say that even one feeding at the breast doesn’t have value, because it does. Whether you nurse for days, weeks, or years, breastfeeding provides both you and your baby with many important benefits – but breastfeeding for a year or longer offers the most advantages.